Following the difficulties faced by some food courts, dark clouds are now beginning to gather over the world of pop-up stores. These are two symbols of the retail revival. In recent years, pop-up shops have proliferated so much in certain neighbourhoods – and particularly during the various Fashion Weeks (of which there are more and more…) – that it is hardly surprising to learn they are now causing some backlash. Are they on the verge of becoming the Airbnbs of the retail world?
In Paris, residents of Rue Nazareth have already voiced their dissatisfaction at the growing number of pop-up shops, which they accuse of contributing to the decline of traditional high-street shops and causing noise due to the various events organised there. Events which are, in fact, the very reason these spaces are rented in the first place… For small brands that have emerged on social media, these short-term rental shops serve not so much to generate sales as to generate buzz and secure visibility online. It is a model designed to foster an emotional sense of community rather than a business model driven by profitability. The result: DJ sets, live music, queues, beer kegs, deckchairs in car parks and, sometimes, at the end of the event, piles of rubbish. Enough to fuel resentment.
This anecdote is revealing of the transformation of cities as much as it is of the transformation of commerce. The commerce of tomorrow will (also) take the form of a succession of temporary activities in the same location, depending on the seasons and current events. The long term will be the sum of short-term periods. Entire, clearly defined neighbourhoods will be primarily aimed at visitors, just as certain Parisian shops, restaurants and cafés already are, thereby contributing to a standardisation of offers and aesthetics. As if a part of the city were being privatised, removed from the public interest. As for the pavements, traditionally reserved for café and restaurant terraces, they will become highly coveted spaces – potential sources of conflict – viewed as outdoor extensions by all coffee shops, pop-up stores and even, now, bakeries.
The city of tomorrow is taking shape before our very eyes, driven by transience rather than permanence, selectivity rather than inclusivity, and the idealisation of moments spent on a terrace.